How Russia Is Trying to Make America’s F-22 and F-35 as Obsolete as Battleships

Charlie Gao
October 14, 2017

Ever since the development of stealth technology for aircraft, many different systems have been advertised as “stealth killing.” One of the more innovative solutions is the Russian Struna-1/Barrier-E bistatic radar system developed by NNIIRT, a division of the Almaz-Antey Joint Stock Company. Almaz-Antey is the premier air-defense and radar manufacturer in Russia; they make the Tor, Buk and S-400 anti-aircraft systems, as well as their respective search radars. The Struna-1 was originally developed in 1999. A further evolution of Struna-1, the Barrier-E system was later showcased for export at MAKS 2007. While it is not part of Almaz-Antey’s online catalog, it was shown alongside other radars at MAKS 2017. The system is rumored to be deployed around Moscow.

The Struna-1 is different than most radars in that it is a bistatic radar, meaning it relies on the receiver and transmitter of the radar to be in two different locations as opposed to conventional radar technology where the receiver and transmitter are located in the same location. Normal radar systems are limited by the inverse fourth power law. As the radar target goes further away from the transmission source, the strength of the radar signal decays as per the regular inverse square law. However, radar detection works by receiving reflections of the radar signal. With a conventional radar, this results in the received signal being four times weaker than that put out. Stealth works because at a distance, an aircraft can mitigate its radar returns to be small by scattering them and absorbing them using radiation-absorbent materials. This degrades the quality of the radar track so it is harder to distinguish precise information about an aircraft.

The Struna-1 solves this problem by positioning the transmitter in a different location than the receiver. The link between the transmitter and receiver has increased power relative to a conventional radar, as it falls off according to the inverse square law as opposed to the inverse fourth power law. This allows the radar to be more sensitive, as it is effectively acting as a radar tripwire. According to Russian sources, this setup increases the effective radar cross section (RCS) of a target by nearly threefold, and ignores any anti-radar coatings that can scatter the radio waves. This allows the detection of not only stealth aircraft, but other objects with low RCS such as hang gliders and cruise missiles. As many of ten receiver/transmitter tower pairs—each tower is called Priyomno-Peredayushchiy Post (PPP) in Russian publications—can be placed. Sources vary in potential configurations of the towers, but the maximum span between two single towers is 50km. This leads to a maximum theoretical perimeter of 500km.

These individual towers have relatively low power consumption, and they do not emit as much energy as traditional radars, making them less vulnerable to anti-radiation weapons. The towers are mobile, allowing for forward deployment in times of conflict. They rely on microwave data links to communicate with each other and a centralized monitoring station, which can be located at a significant distance from the system. The distributed nature also allows the system to keep operating if one node goes down, albeit with less precision. The low height of the transmitter and receiver towers (only 25m off the ground) make Struna-1 very good at detecting low altitude targets, a target set that conventional radars often have trouble with.

Limitations of the Struna-1 include a low detection altitude. The nature of the system results in the detection range being a rough biased parabola between the receiver and transmitter. This limits the detection altitude to around 7km at the tallest point, with the maximum detection range going down as one gets closer to the transmitter/receiver towers. The transverse size of the detection zone islikewise limited, being around 1.5km close to the towers to 12km at the optimal point between the towers. The small size of the detection zone limits the use of the Struna-1 system as a tripwire, it cannot replace traditional radars as an overall search mechanism. However with its high precision tracks of stealthy aircraft, it would serve as a good counterpart to other longer-band radar systems such as Sunflower, which provide less precise tracks of planes. The Struna-1 cannot act as a targeting radar due to its inability to provide constant radar illumination tracking a target, so it cannot be used to guide in semi-active surface-to-air missiles.

While the Struna-1 bistatic radar is not a be-all end-all detection solution for stealth aircraft, it could pose a significant threat to stealth NATO aircraft in a future conflict. Strike aircraft with stealth features are particularly vulnerable, the strike role tends to favor flight profiles that might cause aircraft to fly into the Struna-1’s detection range. In tandem with other modern “stealth-defeating” radar systems, the Struna-1 could provide critical information to an adversary on the position and movement of stealth aircraft.

Charlie Gao studied Political and Computer Science at Grinnell College and is a frequent commentator on defense and national security issues.

Image: Reuters

http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/how-russia-trying-make-americas-f-22-f-35-obsolete-22715

 

 

Advertisements
Standard

Les Kurdes favorables au dialogue avec Bagdad après l’opération militaire

Strategika 51

Le gouvernement du Kurdistan irakien s’est déclaré jeudi favorable à un dialogue avec le pouvoir central à Bagdad dont les forces viennent de chasser les combattants kurdes de zones disputées.
“Le cabinet du Kurdistan accueille favorablement l’initiative du Premier ministre Haider al-Abadi d’entamer des négociations pour régler les problèmes en suspens selon la Constitution et les principes de partenariat”, selon un communiqué officiel publié à Erbil, la capitale du Kurdistan.
Le communiqué a été publié après une réunion du cabinet tenue sous la présidence du Premier ministre kurde Nechervan Barzani et du vice-Premier ministre Qubad Talabani.
“Le Kurdistan demande l’aide et la contribution de la communauté internationale en parrainant ce dialogue”, selon le gouvernement de cette région autonome.
Lundi et mardi, les troupes fédérales irakiennes et des milices alliées ont évincé les forces kurdes de la riche province pétrolière de Kirkouk (nord-est), ainsi que des provinces de Ninive (nord) et…

View original post 381 more words

Standard

Damas cible des avions israéliens au dessus du Liban

Strategika 51

La décision de cibler avec des missiles SAM des avions de combat israéliens violant l’espace aérien du Liban fut ordonnée directement par la présidence syrienne.

Cette décision a été prise en concertation avec l’allié iranien au lendemain d’un bombardement aérien israélien ayant visé des cibles militaires syriennes à partir du Liban et se veut comme un avertissement adressé par l’axe Damas-Téhéran à Tel-Aviv.

C’est la première fois depuis 1983 que les défenses antiaériennes syriennes entrent en action contre des cibles aériennes israéliennes évoluant au dessus du Liban.

D’après les informations disponibles, il ne s’agissait pas d’un vol de reconnaissance mais d’une formation en ordre de combat.  Les israéliens ont d’ailleurs riposté en tirant des missiles anti-radar (ARM) sur une batterie de missiles Sol-Air syrienne située à 50 km à l’Est de Damas. Un avion de combat de type F-35 aurait été gravement endommagé lors d’une manœuvre d’esquive après l’échec des…

View original post 304 more words

Standard

Analyse sur le rapprochement entre la Turquie et l’Iran

Strategika 51

Etude de Cemil Dogac Ipek, docteur en Relations internationales à l’Université Ataturk

Analyse sur le rapprochement entre la Turquie et l’Iran

          L’Iran et la Turquie sont deux puissances régionales qui partagent une frontière de 560 kilomètres qui n’a pas changé depuis près de 4 siècles. Outre l’ambassade de la Turquie à Téhéran, la Turquie a un consulat général à Tabriz, Ourmia et Masshad. L’Iran a de son côté comme représentation en Turquie, l’ambassade d’Iran à Ankara et les consulats généraux d’Istanbul, d’Erzurum et de Trabzon. La Turquie vise à développer ses relations avec l’Iran, sur les principes de respect, de bon voisinage et de ne pas se mêler des affaires internes entre eux. Les deux pays font des efforts en vue de développer et faire avancer le dialogue politique et les relations bilatérales via les visites réciproques de hauts rangs réalisées en particulier ces derniers temps.

L’un des résultats du référendum illégal d’indépendance tenu il y a quelques…

View original post 759 more words

Standard

The story of another time the US considered attacking North Korea

Strategika 51

Writer Todd Crowell recalls events when Richard Nixon was president of the US and Washington was considering an attack on North Korea.

MAY 2, 2017 4:55 PM (UTC+8)

Recent headlines suggest the United States is considering a range of “options” to curb North Korea’s nuclear weapons and missile ambitions, up to and including air strikes.

What seems to have been forgotten is that there was a moment between the two countries in the past that also involved the planning of an air attack by the US.

Though it eventually never took place, it’s not as easy for me to forget, as I was personally involved.

There was nothing to indicate that the day April 15, 1969, would be any different from any other day as winter gave way to cherry blossom season in Japan.

I was a young air force lieutenant stationed with the 347th Fighter Wing…

View original post 866 more words

Standard